After I identified a promising range of powder weights using Audetter’s ladder test, my next step was to use Dan Newberry’s Optimal Charge Weight (OCW) Method to offset the “scatter node” drawback inherently present in the ladder test. To learn more about that, read this article comparing the OCW method with the ladder test.
The OCW method is based on the observation that there are some loads out there (like Federal’s match ammo for the 308) that shoot really well out of just about any rifle. How can one recipe shoot so well out of so many different rifles? Dan Newberry believes accuracy of great “pet loads” are due to how well they match up with the shockwave that traverses a barrel when firing a rifle. The theory behind it is kind of complex, so for more info … see Dan’s overview on how it works.
Although the theory behind the OCW method is complex … it’s actually pretty easy to perform. You simply identify a range of powder weights you want to try, fire a 3 shot group of each powder charge, then identify the groups that come closest to hitting the same point of impact (POI) on the target. As Dan Newberry examples, “The trend of the groups should be obvious, normally going from low and favoring one side, to high and favoring the other side. But along the progression, there should be a string of at least three groups that all hit the target in the same relative point.” You can then choose the powder charge that represents the center of that string, which should be a very “pressure tolerant” or “resilient” load. That should mean that slight variations in pressure due to differences in powder charge, primer “hotness”, neck tension, bullet runout, etc. won’t have have a dramatic input on groups.
Based on my results from the Audette’s Ladder test, I decided to try the Berger 168gr VLD over Retumbo powder ranging from 68.9gr to 70.1gr. Note: The OCW method recommends jumping in 3 grain increments for magnums, and 2 grain increments for standard cartridges. Sorry I didn’t record velocities … it was already too dark for my chronograph when I started.
The white cross on each target represents the center point of impact (POI) for each 3-shot group. What we want to do now is look for the 3 targets where that white cross is the closest to the same position. You can see the POI for the first group was well below the bull, the 3 middle targets all group just to the right and slightly above the bull, and the last target grouped ever higher up well above the bull. Here is a graphical summary of the POIs from each of the 5 targets. You can clearly see targets 2, 3 & 4 had virtually identical POIs.
So based on results from the OCW method, it’s pretty clear cut that 69.2gr to 69.8gr have very similar point of impacts. That not only confirms the results from the ladder test, but gives me further detail about where the most accurate and “resilient” load is … right around 69.5gr of Retumbo. Next time I’ll test 5 shot groups at more precise powder weight increments in that range, and hopefully zero in on my final powder charge.
Note: The software I used for the target analysis shown here is very handy when doing load development, and fairly simple to use. It’s called OnTarget, and just costs $12. Here is a link to their website: OnTargetShooting.com.
Jump to another step:
- Part 1: Bullet Selection & Real-World Velocities
- Part 2: Audette’s Ladder Test
- Part 3: Optimal Charge Weight
- Part 4: 5 Shot Groups